ESG Investing and Fiduciaries—A Forced Marriage?

The Biden Administration is working on a regulation which will reverse a Trump regulation which restricted the ESG program.

The forthcoming Biden regulation is a pacesetter because:

  • It is a formal rulemaking issued by the Department of Labor
  • Virtually every major player will submit comments, and
  • Most importantly there is a private sector enforcement mechanism which could keep the participants honest.
 Private Sector Enforcement Mechanism

Here is the textbook definition of an ESG Investment Fund:

“ESG funds are portfolios of equities and/or bonds for which environmental, social and governance factors have been integrated into the investment process. This means the equities and bonds contained in the fund have passed stringent tests over how sustainable the company or government is regarding its ESG criteria.”

Regarding stringent tests, CRE was instrumental in passing the Information [Data] Quality Act which sets standards that all data issued by federal agencies must meet and contains a process for the public to file petitions for incorrect data disseminated by federal agencies, see this press article.  The IQA could be heart of a public  enforcement mechanism.

 A Challenging Issue: A Pecuniary Responsibility for ESG Fund Managers?

“A fiduciary is legally bound to put their client’s best interests ahead of their own. Registered investment advisors have a fiduciary duty to clients; broker-dealers just have to meet the less-stringent suitability standard, which doesn’t require putting the client’s interests ahead of their own.

In the EU and the UK  It has been the subject of extensive debate whether investment managers and other institutional investors are permitted and/or required to consider ESG issues when discharging duties to their clients or beneficiaries. Institutional investors have traditionally viewed their duties as being defined exclusively by the pursuit of financial returns, causing them necessarily to dismiss ESG issues as being non-financial, ethical or moral considerations which should not be taken into account. However, there has been a shift in thinking among industry stakeholders, policymakers and regulators alike toward viewing ESG issues as being financial risks which impact investment performance. This has resulted in legislative and regulatory change in the UK and EU seeking to clarify that ESG issues are financially material, which may in turn impact the interpretation of investment managers’ fiduciary duties, tortious and contractual duties, in addition to their regulatory duties. (Investopedia)

There are important questions around whether the consideration of ESG factors is consistent with the fiduciary duties of investment managers and other institutional investors. There has been a series of research papers, coordinated by the United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative (UNEP FI), analysing fiduciary duties and the consideration of ESG factors on a cross-jurisdictional basis. Three reports have been published so far: the Freshfields Report (2005);  Fiduciary II (2009);  and Fiduciary Duty in the 21st Century (2015).  The central argument of the UNEP FI is that the integration of ESG considerations into investment decision making is consistent with the fiduciary duties of institutional investors as these are long-term investment value drivers.  As such, UNEP FI concludes that investment approaches which take into account ESG factors are clearly permissible and arguably required.”

We believe the aforementioned concern will be central to the forthcoming rulemaking.

The OMB Comment Period: The Ultimate Resolution Forum

OIRA (Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs) could have a major impact on the substance of the rule.

 CRE will be filing comments on the proposed rule when OMB releases it for public comments.

 ESG Data and Analytics

The timely and effective implementation of a sustainable ESG program is dependent upon accurate ESG data and its complementary analytical initiatives.  This Interactive Public Docket (IPD) is designed to achieve the aforementioned objections.

 

 

 

 

24 comments. Leave a Reply

  1. Seth Morris

    How is it possible to find a comprehensive list of beneficial exemplification essay topics? Browse the company website and relish the choice you have. Only the most relevant themes, great examples, and impressive ideas. Easy way to academic success.
    https://superbgrade.com/blog/50-good-exemplification-essay-topics-ideas

  2. rosaanderson

    A forced marriage! Attractive blog! I really appreciate the discussion style and the points you have discussed mark wahlberg tracksuit in this forum are mind blowing. Good luck

  3. Ronald Tolkien

    Students, I feel that I must tell this. Within the last year, a bunch of private troubles combined with countless college assignments resulted in a depression for me. If you feel that you are about to quit everything, go my way: visit https://proessays.net/. They can save your grades while you save yourself.

  4. Amazon book publisher services

    Amazon book publisher services titles can be evaluated and published in as little as 72 hours, while low-content novels can take up to 10 business days. Your book is now being published and will soon be available on the Amazon store.

  5. harry potter

    Papershelm reviews your foremost choice for academic writing services. We take the hassle out of order process by making user-friendly add-ons available at every step.
    https://issuu.com/papershelm-reviews

  6. Mark spencer

    Papersnow reviews is uniquely qualified to provide perfect solutions for your writing, editing and proofreading problems.
    https://www.reviewcentre.com/education_websites/papers_now_-_wwwpapersnowcouk-reviews_4206171

  7. berry233

    Students or professionals can easily get any type of writing work done in any subject and at any level of education they want. The writers at IntellectualsDen are experts and know how to produce some really high-quality content for its customers.
    https://scamsoldier.com/review/intellectualsden.com

  8. Rebecca McGuiness

    TopResume (https://top-resume-reviews.com/services/skillhub) is a highly reputable resume writing service that has been helping job seekers for many years. With its team of experienced writers and personalized approach, TopResume has helped thousands of clients to create professional and effective resumes that stand out in the job market.

    The service offers a range of packages to suit different needs and budgets, and its writers are experts in various industries and fields. With TopResume, clients can expect a collaborative and customized approach to resume writing, with a focus on highlighting their unique skills and achievements.

    If you’re looking for a top-quality resume writing service, TopResume is definitely worth considering. With its positive reviews and track record of success, it’s a useful source for job seekers who want to make a great first impression.

  9. DavidMaltson

    My experience working with Jacob Mercari https://jacobmercari.com/ to create an engagement ring for my fiancé was exceptional. Ensuring that the diamonds in my chosen engagement ring were certified by reputable organizations was crucial to me, as this provides a guarantee of their quality and authenticity. The availability of custom design services at Jacob Mercari caught my attention, as it gave me the opportunity to craft a distinctive and unparalleled piece that perfectly captured the essence of my bride. I want to give special recognition to Gregory for his professionalism and transparency. He provided invaluable advice and direction, helping me choose the ideal jewelry design that fulfilled all of my requirements while staying within budget.

  10. tracymarchs

    Draws in new talent – It is essential for your business to expand within your industry to recruit top talent. Your recruiting efforts may benefit from implementing employee recognition programs and distributing them to potential new hires.

  11. Den345

    Casino for money is a very profitable way to earn decent money today. What I like most is slot machines for real money. But sometimes I can play at the GGBet https://ggbet-fi.com/ The game process itself is very interesting from the very beginning until the moment when you look at the screen and wait for something to come out. The excitement is off the charts! And you can raise money

  12. LunwenHelp

    Our team of assignment writers consists of members with strong academic backgrounds, relevant professional qualifications, and extensive experience in assignment writing https://www.lunwenhelp.com/assignment-daixie/ . Regardless of the field you are studying, you can confidently entrust your assignment writing tasks to us. Your success in graduation and a bright future are our primary motivation and ultimate goal. Place your order now and reap the benefits of our outstanding assignment writing services as soon as possible.

  13. darcy fix

    I can say this is an outstanding article for the readers . please visit and gather newly words through this website . i have something about daily wear tvjacket

  14. meeloun education

    留学生构思美国论文时是像写日记一样平铺直叙还是会先列大纲让你的写作事半功倍呢?不要在写美国论文时握笔苦思冥想啦,其实写大纲并不难,接下来我将跟大家讲一讲美国论文代写 https://www.lxws.net/usadaixie.html 大纲怎么完成。

  15. Sylv

    Witaj w naszym kasynie online – miejscu rozrywki i szczęścia! Oferujemy bogatą gamę gier, w tym slotów, pokeru i ruletki. Nasza platforma zapewnia emocjonujące doświadczenia dzięki najnowszym technologiom. Skorzystaj z naszego hojnego bonusu powitalnego gra Plinko i zanurz się w fascynującym świecie hazardu. Wygrywaj z nami i odkryj tajemnice szczęścia! Spróbuj teraz! Vulkan Vegas czeka na Ciebie!

  16. Den

    In my experience, only a few casinos offer great bonuses. I am almost sure that Hit n Spin Casino online casino https://hitnspin.pl/ will make your life better, because its goal is not to steal money, but to be honest with you. You may not believe me, so in that case you can read real reviews.

  17. zara doyle

    Impressive working style. i cant wait anymore to see something more advantage able for all of us. Ferrari Vintage F1 Jacket

  18. Deniskos

    The demo version allows you to better understand the slot and get acquainted with the rules. Try playing for free to better understand the capabilities of the slot and then start playing for real money Hit n Spin Casino https://hitnspincasino.com/de/

  19. Anonymous

    Przyjdź do naszego przytulnego Hit n Spin Casino https://hitnspin.casino/pl/, gdzie każdy gracz jest mile widziany. Nasza profesjonalna obsługa oraz bogata oferta gier sprawią, że Twój pobyt będzie pełen emocji i niezapomnianych przeżyć.

  20. Anonymous

    Odkryj niepowtarzalny świat hazardu w naszym ekskluzywnym kasynie mr bet https://mrbet-casino.pl/, gdzie każdy detal został dopracowany, aby zapewnić Ci wyjątkowe doznania. Czekają tu na Ciebie nie tylko emocjonujące gry, ale także luksusowe udogodnienia i doskonała atmosfera.

  21. Anonymous

    Witamy w naszym prestiżowym kompleksie kasynowym, gdzie elegancja i rozrywka spotykają się w jednym miejscu. Znajdziesz tu wszystko Vulkan Bet https://vulkanbet-online.club/pl/, czego potrzebujesz, by poczuć się jak prawdziwy gracz – od klasycznych gier stołowych po nowoczesne automaty do gry.

  22. Anonymous

    Przekrocz progi naszego nowoczesnego kasyna i poddaj się magii hazardu w najwyższym wydaniu. Nasze wysokie standardy obsługi oraz różnorodność gier zapewnią Ci niezapomniane chwile Vulkan Vegas kasyno https://vulkanvegas-gry.org/sugar-rush/, które zostaną w Twojej pamięci na długo.

  23. sam 8659960

    Databricks-Certified Professional Data Engineer certification can be a game-changer for your career. By mastering the essential topics, gaining hands-on experience, and leveraging available study resources, you can confidently pass the certification https://www.myexamcollection.com/Databricks-Certified-Professional-Data-Engineer-vce-questions.htm exam and unlock new opportunities in the field of data engineering.

  24. Deniskos444

    Na minha experiência, apenas alguns casinos oferecem grandes bónus. Tenho quase a certeza que o cassino GG Bet https://gg-bet-casino.com/pt/ vai melhorar a sua vida, porque o seu objetivo não é roubar dinheiro, mas sim ser honesto consigo. Pode ser que não acredite em mim, por isso, nesse caso, pode ler as opiniões reais.

Leave a Reply

Please Answer: *