Issues

Complaints
Funding
Governance
MOU
Responsiveness
Transparency

CRE Interventions
  Agency Administrative Actions
  Rulemaking
  Litigation

Government
  Federal Computer Incident Response Center
  National Infrastructure Protection Center
  National Telecommunications and Information Administration
 US Department of Commerce
 US Office of Management and Budget

NGO's
  Domain Name Rights Coalition
  Electronics Frontiers Foundation
  gTLD-MoU
  ICANN at Large
  Internet Society
  The Non-Commercial Domain Name Holders Constituency

Technical Orgs
CERT Coordination Center
Internet Architecture Board
Internet Assigned Numbers Authority
Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers
Internet Engineering Task Force
Internet Mail Consortium
Internet Research Task Center
Requests for Comments Editor

 

A Premature Announcement
According to a current press report, ICANN's President and CEO has indicated that the corporation "would cut its ties" with the Department of Commerce (DOC) when the current Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) expires in 2006. The news story also stated that ICANN is determined "not be under the authority of any international organisation" such as the UN.

ICANN's intent to remain independent of the UN is praiseworthy. However, their apparent belief that the corporation will automatically become independent of the US government in 2006 is more than a bit premature. Although the Department has made clear in the most recent amendment to the DOC – ICANN MOU that they support "the policy of privatizing the technical management of the Internet and its underlying domain name system..." such privatization is not automatically conferred on ICANN in 2006.

As DOC explained in their statement accompanying the signing of the most recent amendment to the MOU, "as both the Department and ICANN recognize, much work remains for ICANN to evolve into an independent, stable, and sustainable DNS management organization." The ongoing need for ICANN reform is reiterated in the Department's FY ‘05 Annual Performance Plan which states that a "number of Internet related policy issues will require NTIA action, including ICANN reform..."

Although the DOC statement on the MOU extension explains that the MOU's three year time frame "should provide sufficient time for this work to be accomplished" there is no guarantee that such accomplishments will actually be achieved. In recognition of the "much work" that needs to be successfully accomplished before ICANN could become independent of the government, the MOU details specific milestones and a time line "intended to ensure ICANN is a sufficiently stable, transparent, representative, efficient, and sustainable management organization capable of handling the important DNS tasks well into the future." [emphasis added]

Thus, if ICANN is to become independent of DOC in 2006, the corporation will need to:

  1. Successfully complete all of the requirements of the MOU; and


  2. Openly and transparently document successful completion of the MOU tasks.
  • Click to see news story

  • Copyright © 2005 The Center for Regulatory Effectiveness.
    All rights reserved.