Issues

Complaints
Funding
Governance
MOU
Responsiveness
Transparency

CRE Interventions
  Agency Administrative Actions
  Rulemaking
  Litigation

Government
  Federal Computer Incident Response Center
  National Infrastructure Protection Center
  National Telecommunications and Information Administration
 US Department of Commerce
 US Office of Management and Budget

NGO's
  Domain Name Rights Coalition
  Electronics Frontiers Foundation
  gTLD-MoU
  ICANN at Large
  Internet Society
  The Non-Commercial Domain Name Holders Constituency

Technical Orgs
CERT Coordination Center
Internet Architecture Board
Internet Assigned Numbers Authority
Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers
Internet Engineering Task Force
Internet Mail Consortium
Internet Research Task Center
Requests for Comments Editor

 

On To Africa
According to an ICANN Press Release, the corporation is seeking to discuss "the growing involvement of Africa in the core Internet structures." Furthermore, ICANN seeks to engage the African community "in identifying appropriate modes and locations on the African continent for an ICANN regional presence and how a local presence can assist with operational issues."

Nominally, ICANN's interest in expanding operations in Africa appears to be both beneficial and in keeping with the requirements of their MOU with the Department of Commerce. Section II.C.9 of the 6th Amendment to the MOU calls for the corporation to "develop, to test, and to implement appropriate mechanisms that foster informed participation in ICANN by the global Internet community, such as providing educational services and fostering information sharing for constituents and promoting best practices among industry segments."

However, ICANN's new African Initiative raises as many questions as it answers. For example, the Press Release stated that ICANN is "seeking input from the African community on the key form and functions most important to Africa." The question is, which groups and/or organizations in Africa will ICANN be seeking input from? There is no question that Africa has the potential to make major contributions to the international communications revolution exemplified by the internet to the benefit of both the continent and the world.

However, it also true that many groups in Africa suffer from substantial repression because of ethnic, religious and/or political discrimination. Sudan and Zimbabwe are among the most notorious but not only examples of this type of repressive situation. Will ICANN actively solicit input from oppressed groups and peoples, many of who could well benefit from the internet to communicate their situation to the wider world?

Unfortunately, ICANN's Press Release give little hope that the corporation will do little other than focus their attention on the dominant power groups and states. For example, the Press Release states that ICANN "will seek participation of local entities in establishing an African presence, including potentially the donation of infrastructure, office space, and staffing." However, it seems quite unlikely that refugees in Darfur or political dissidents in Zimbabwe would be in a position to provide ICANN with the requested resources. Furthermore, there is no indication that ICANN has any intention of potentially alienating ruling governments by reaching out to oppressed peoples.

ICANN has the potential to bring communication and information benefits to diverse peoples in Africa. Alternatively, the corporation could focus their attention and resources to the benefit of the existing power structures. Regrettably, ICANN has not yet shown any inclination to reach beyond the continent's elite political establishment and engage in dialog with those most in need.

  • Read ICANN Press Release

  • Copyright © 2005 The Center for Regulatory Effectiveness.
    All rights reserved.