Issues

Complaints
Funding
Governance
MOU
Responsiveness
Transparency

CRE Interventions
  Agency Administrative Actions
  Rulemaking
  Litigation

Government
  Federal Computer Incident Response Center
  National Infrastructure Protection Center
  National Telecommunications and Information Administration
 US Department of Commerce
 US Office of Management and Budget

NGO's
  Domain Name Rights Coalition
  Electronics Frontiers Foundation
  gTLD-MoU
  ICANN at Large
  Internet Society
  The Non-Commercial Domain Name Holders Constituency

Technical Orgs
CERT Coordination Center
Internet Architecture Board
Internet Assigned Numbers Authority
Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers
Internet Engineering Task Force
Internet Mail Consortium
Internet Research Task Center
Requests for Comments Editor

 

Should ICANN Require Use of DNS-Sec?
Domain Name System-Security (DNS-Sec) is a soon to be released standard for "authenticating data moving across the Internet, making it more difficult for people dispensing spam, viruses and worms to remain anonymous." However, for the security standard to be effective, it would need to be adopted by top level domain holders. Furthermore, "private companies with their own DNS servers, Internet service providers and telecommunications companies would also have to agree to deploy the security standard..." There would be significant costs involved in deploying DNS-Sec, for the technology and for "a new layer of administration for managing the security mechanism." InternetWeek noted that "Many experts believe most businesses do not see the need for DNS-Sec today." Despite the expected reluctance of businesses to deploy the technology, one analyst quoted in the article stated that, "At some point, ICANN, with the support of government and industry associations, will have to make DNS-Sec a requirement, to push adoption faster than a snail's pace." The article also noted that "ICANN is a big supporter of DNS-Sec." The question of whether and/or when the benefits of DNS-Sec would exceed the costs is complex. Of particular interest is the process by which ICANN evaluates DNS-Sec and any policies they develop based on their evaluation or other factors.


Copyright © 2005 The Center for Regulatory Effectiveness.
All rights reserved.