View past CRE Regulatory Action of the Week items
The AAHRPP Is A New Voluntary Accreditation And
Consensus Standards Setting Body for Human Subjects Research
The Association for the Accreditation of Human
Research Protection Programs was incorporated as a nonprofit in 2001 to serve as
a voluntary accreditation and standards setting body for human research
protection programs. The AAHRPP’s press release explains that it "offers
accreditation to institutions engaged in research involving human participants
using a voluntary, peer-driven, educational model."
The AAHRPP was founded by the following nonprofit
member organizations:
- Association of American Medical Colleges
- Association of American Universities
- Consortium of Social Science Associations
- Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology
- National Association of State Universities and Land Grant Colleges
- National Health Council
- Public Responsibility in Medicine and Research
The AAHRPP will charge institutions an
application fee for AAHRPP accreditation.
The AAHRPP’s first goal is to develop a set of
performance standards for human subjects research. It plans on pilot-testing
these standards by the end of summer. Institutions performing human subjects
research would perform two assessments of their compliance with these
performance standards: a first "self assessment"; and a second on-site
assessment by the AAHRPP. At the end of this process, assuming the institution
passed, it would be accredited by the AAHRPP.
The AAHRPP will be headquartered in Rockville,
Maryland. Its 21-person Board is now conducting an intensive search for an
Executive Director.
The AAHRPP’s potential is very interesting. The
Federal Government is reviewing its regulation of human subjects research. The
National Bioethics Advisory Commission has now issued its reports on
international and domestic human subject research issues. The NBAC reports
contain sweeping recommendations for reform, focusing on more stringent and
pervasive federal regulation. Institutional accreditation and performance
standards are primary issues in what may be dramatic regulatory change.
A new office within HHS, the Office of Human
Research Protections, has been created to oversea this regulatory review and
change. The OHRP favors the type of voluntary accreditation program exemplified
by the AAHRPP.
Performance and accreditation standards developed
by the AAHRPP could be voluntary consensus standards under the federal
Technology Transfer Act, 15 U.S.C. § 272 note, and OMB Circular A-119. If so,
then any federal agency revising its human research regulations or policies may
be statutorily required to adopt the AAHRPP standards unless they were for some
reason impracticable or inconsistent with applicable law. In addition, under the
Tech Transfer Act and the OMB Circular the Government could be obliged to
participate in development of the AAHRPP standards.
Given this potential, and given CRE’s
long-standing interest in both human testing and voluntary standards setting
bodies, we intend to follow the AAHRPP’s progress and report further on it in
the CRE website.